The Useless Microphone
I‘m sitting in an audience, straining to hear the speaker. “Why?” you ask. I’ll tell you. The microphone is too far away from the dude’s mouth. All he needed to do was move closer to the microphone, and, BAM, his little voice would be amplified, and we’d hear him.
But he doesn’t.
Why do rational people refuse to use microphones? Why do they believe that the conversation level of their voices will carry through a large room?
I once sat in a large meeting room in San Antonio, Texas, that could hold 500 people. An Army JAG Colonel was talking about career progression in the JAG Corps. I was interested, but I couldn’t hear her.
Why?
When she stood up to speak, the first (correct) thing she did was pull the microphone to her mouth. That’s usually where the human voice emanates.
Everything was going well for about .02 seconds until she heard her voice broadcast over the speakers. Maybe she had never heard her voice before. Maybe she was expecting a pleasant Lauren Bacall voice to come out, and it didn’t, shocking her.
I don’t know. But she looked at the innocent microphone.
And frowned.
The next (incorrect) thing she did was to say, “I don’t need this thing, do I? Y’all can hear me, can’t cha?” When a colonel asks an audience question that requires an affirmative answer, the audience complies.
They also agree and keep quiet.
She put the microphone down on one of the front chairs and continued her talk – a talk that no one in the audience heard.
‘Well, no, Ma’am. No, we can’t hear you,’ is what someone should have said.
Of course, not me, but someone. I was a lowly captain and wanted to use the career progression she was discussing.
But here’s what I thought: ‘We can’t hear you now that you’ve removed the one thing that would have amplified your voice throughout the room and ensured that the audience understood your intended communication.’
Unless she didn’t intend to be heard.
Which, I suppose, is a possibility.
But, as I said, I keep my mouth shut.
Why don’t people use microphones? That’s why they’re there. Why are some folks scared of their own voices?
I suppose there are a lot of reasons. But here’s my philosophy: If you are in a profession that requires that you give speeches from time to time, learn to love, or at least like, your voice. Seriously, Go to a Roger Love seminar or Toastmasters meeting or something. For an excellent article on how to give great presentations, you don’t have to go any further from this domain to read Jason Shen’s “How to Dramatically Improve your Public Speaking Skills.”
I think there should be penalties for higher-ranking officers who refuse to use microphones where they are required. For example, you’re demoted to private and have to clean the kitchen in a remote military post near the Arctic Circle.
Or something like that.
A few years after the San Antonio conference, the Army, in its wisdom, held a ceremony, promoted that Colonel to the rank of General, and gave her a chance to give a talk. No word if anyone there heard what she said.
